Every electrician picks a side, at least to start: union (IBEW) or non-union (open shop). It affects your starting pay, your benefits, how you train, and how fast you get hired. Here's the straight comparison so you can choose what fits your market and your goals.
When you get into electrical work, you'll go one of two ways: union (the IBEW, paired with NECA contractors) or non-union / open shop (often through the IEC — Independent Electrical Contractors — or just hired direct by a shop). Both lead to a journeyman license. They just get there differently, and they pay and operate differently.
The IBEW apprenticeship (run through joint apprenticeship training committees, or JATCs) is the gold-standard structured path. You earn a scheduled wage that steps up roughly every 1,000 hours, get health insurance and a pension, and train to a consistent standard. Union scale in strong markets is the highest pay in the trade — top IBEW locals in big cities run well over $100/hour in total compensation including benefits.
The trade-offs: you go where the work is dispatched, you pay union dues, and in some regions the work is less steady between big projects. But for benefits, training quality, and ceiling pay, the union is tough to beat.
Non-union electricians often train through the IEC or learn on the job with a private contractor. Apprentice pay typically starts a bit lower than union scale, and benefits vary by employer. The upside is flexibility — you can often get hired faster, work is common in growing Sun Belt markets, and strong performers can negotiate raises directly rather than waiting on a fixed scale.
Open-shop electricians also frequently log more overtime hours in busy markets, which narrows the annual pay gap with the union even when the hourly base is lower.
Honest answer: it depends on your market and what you value. In a strong union town, the IBEW's pay, pension, and benefits are hard to argue with. In a fast-growing open-shop region, non-union work can get you hired quickly with plenty of overtime. Many electricians work both sides over a career.
The thing that matters most either way is getting your hours and your license — that's what makes you a journeyman, union or not. Pick the route that gets you working and learning fastest in your area.
Compare lifetime earnings, debt, and net worth — trade vs a four-year degree, side by side.
Run the Wealth Calculator → Find scholarships →